Monticello IN Real Estate & Homes for Sale

A very well maintained lake get a way. This 3 bed 2 bath home has nice decks overlooking Lake Shafer with a permanent boat lift on the water. There is a 2 plus garage with lots of room for storage and recreation. The property is part of the Golden Beach Club and offers a boat launch, volleyball court, a pavilion, play ground and additional parking

Beautifully remodeled, lake level, Lake freeman home with multiple decks and gorgeous views. Home is raised with a full size 9ft crawl space below with overhead door perfect for storage and water toys. In addition you have a detached garage for parking and room for your guests parking. Waterfront includes 60 feet of water frontage, a steel driven seawall, permanent covered boat lift, and a roof top wrap around deck perfect for entertaining and all the views! Interior of the home offers 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, updated roof, electrical, windows and floor coverings. This is an excellent waterfront lake home, with a convenient location, just a few minutes to town and just down the street there is a boat launch and Bluewater park.

Custom built 3 story home with a full basement in the heart of Monticello. Small town living at its best with close proximity to schools. This lovely home has 5 (possibly 6) bedrooms, 2.5 baths, a large family room with an open kitchen, dining room, living room, and extra space in the basement area. This house features carpet, and tile throughout the house with a fireplace insert in the living room. There is also a large fenced in back yard with an in-ground heated pool for all your entertaining needs. Also features an oversized 2 car detached garage. This home will not last long. Call us today to schedule your appointment to view this gorgeous home and make it your own.

Great potential with this 3.52 Acre parcel that has access to Lake Shafer! It has a 30' x 40' pole barn with water and electricity, and has 3 mobile homes with water, sewer, gas, and electricity that you could fix up and live in or rent them out or remove and build your Dream Home! Has waterfront access to 22' x 72' property in the back of the canal that the Lighthouse Lodge is on. Note: Sq Ft and Bd/Ba are from Mobile Homes Combined and each are 2Bd/1Ba separately.

A darling 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom home only a short distance from Meadowlawn Elementary and Bluewater Beach Park on the Tippecanoe River. Open concept living room, dining room, and kitchen. Master bedroom with hardwood floors. This home sits on almost a quarter of an acre with mature trees and a detached oversized 1 car garage. Close to schools, downtown Monticello, and Voigt Park complete with an Olympic-size swimming pool, softball diamonds, sand volleyball court, basketball court, playground, and pavilions.

If you are looking for a LAKE LEVEL property that offers year round living or just a summer get away this LAKE FREEMAN home offers it all! Enjoy the huge backyard with a beautiful paver patio area, outdoor bar, firepit, permanent boat lift, deck on the water, jet ski lifts & storage area. This maintenance free home has plenty of room for guests with 3 bedrooms & 2.5 baths, bunk room, open floor plan, cathedral ceilings, recessed lighting, engineered wood flooring, first floor en suite, walk-in closets, 2 living room areas, white wood plank walls throughout & main level laundry. The eat-in kitchen offers a breakfast bar, tile backsplash, stainless steel appliances & quartz countertops. The bay is great for swimming and just a short drive to Lafayette. This charming home is inviting with all the recent updates and will not disappoint!

Welcome to 946 Mitchell Ave. Location, Location, Location!! This lovely 3 bedroom, 1 bath home is located in a beautiful neighborhood close to Bluewater park and in a quiet setting with easy access to other needs and amenities. This home has many positive attributes, such as; newer updates in the kitchen, new/extra insulation in the attic, a new storage shed in the back, HVAC is only about 6 years young and a new professionally installed roof with a transferrable warranty. This would make a lovely place for you to call home! Inspections are certainly welcome, but home is being sold As-Is.

Not only does this home sit on a prime piece of Lake Shafer but it is filled with tons of aesthetic updates as well as all the "behind the scenes" type of updates you want in a home! For starters the walkout basement has been completely finished with a second kitchen and living space. There are new water repellant Armstrong floors throughout the home, all new Anderson windows throughout the home as well as new Anderson sliders leading to the deck & patio. The windows in the upstairs living room and dining room have automatic blinds controlled by remote. All new appliances throughout the home and are fed with a newly installed 200 amp service with a 100 amp sub panel in the basement. The container for the salt is in the garage so you don't have to lug all those heavy bags downstairs! A high efficiency radiant heat furnace has been installed and is set up as a 2 zone system so you can control upstairs and downstairs separately! More updates include new decks, continuous hot water system, whole house water filter, new interior shutters & new A/C unit! All this with amazing views of Lake Shafer and Indiana Beach! Call me today to set up your showing!

Completely rebuilt home from the floor joists up this 3 bedroom, 3 full bath home is located in a private setting on the upper Northern part of Lake Freeman. Open concept kitchen-living room with walk out deck for cookouts and a view of the water. Kitchen has quartz countertops, induction stovetop/oven, and an island with seating. Hardwood floors on main level. Custom tile in all bathrooms. Large master bedroom is on the second level with a walkout deck and water views. Furnace on main and second level. Retaining wall was built along with a paved driveway.

This amazing brick home features 3 bedrooms, 2 full-baths and is one of the most solidly built homes in town. The home has solid 3/4 inch wood floors throughout, 2 fireplaces and an amazing partially finished basement. Moving to the exterior, you will find a mature landscaped yard, newer fencing and a large attached garage. Properties like this do not come along very often, so you had better hurry and set your showing soon!

Big views of the Big Monon Bay of Lake Shafer! Beautiful views, a peaceful waterfront setting and only minutes to the action of the main lake. Enjoy sunny days and star filled nights on the large all composite wrap around lakeside deck. This house is nearly new with all of the updates within the last 5 years. Updates include roof, vinyl siding, stone gas log fireplace, windows, doors, bathrooms, kitchen, spray foam insulation, light fixtures/fans, plumbing, electrical panel, reverse osmosis, garage door, well, and the composite deck. Interior layout offers an open concept floorplan along with an abundance of windows for panoramic views. Ample storage offered from the 1.5 car garage, shed and walk in closets. Get your boat ready! There's a covered electric permanent boat lift. Great neighborhood, location, updated house and huge views. Lake living at its finest!

A PLACE FOR YOU ON THE TIPPECANOE & SHAFER TOO! Thanks to this newly remodeled waterfront cottage and its location, the only thing you'll have to worry about is: relax and enjoy the scenic Tippecanoe or head South and play on Lake Shafer! This waterfront get-away has been completely stripped down and redone from the inside out, from flooring, kitchen, bathroom, walls, lighting, and plumbing to electrical, roof, appliances and more. Located just North of Lake Shafer, this lake-level lot is tucked away under plenty of sunshine & shade across from the wooded scout camp. Steel seawall, 30 x 12 covered deck overlooking the water, carport, plus plenty of parking are all an added 'plus', making this the perfect place for you!

This Lake Freeman home sets on a large lot that has 112 ft of canal frontage. Benefits of living on a canal include a quiet setting, ease of boat docking, and more "elbow room" between neighbors. A private lot with mature trees, beautiful landscaping and easy access to Lake Freeman and town. Inside offers 3 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, huge primary bedroom suite, 2204 sqft and tons of updates. Updates include all new windows (lifetime warranty), new roof in 2020, remodeled primary suite bathroom and guest bathroom, stainless steel oven, new flooring in laundry room along with a new sink, and more! Interior features include an open concept floor plan, gas fireplace, large sunroom, plant house, and a spacious kitchen with 2 pantries. Need storage or a nice workshop?? Look no further! An attached and insulated 2.5 car garage (24x46) that includes 2 work shop areas with an overhead door for easy access. Minutes from the main lake and minutes from town makes this a great home on the lake!

Rare find with 6.26 acres! This mini farm is close to shopping, Indiana Beach and TCC! 4-bedrooms, 2 full baths, with spacious three-season room. Separated from bedrooms and living spaces, a private master or at home office is possible with this split layout. Concrete block home. Other features: 12' x 20' beauty salon room, large garage, parking for 6+ cars, pole barn, and 2 sheds. Outbuildings and acreage, over the years have housed show goats, chickens, horses and a donkey. Newer Lennox gas furnace and Central Air. Oh, the possibilities! Call today for your exclusive showing. Zoned A-1

Rare opportunity to own a 3 bed, 2 bath, ranch style home, custom built in 2010 on Lake Shafer. Perfectly situated on main lake, minutes from the busy southern part of the lake and minutes from the calm northern part of the lake. The professionally landscaped exterior features 75 feet of prime water frontage, 3 car heated garage with an extended 30 foot boat bay, new permanent electric double boat house w/ jetski lift, covered front porch, composite back-deck with retractable SunSetter awning, ample natural shade, and an additional 251'x65' lot ready for your pole barn. As you enter the home, you're met with a spacious open-concept split floor-plan featuring water views throughout. Attention to detail is in abundance with high end fixtures and finishes. Details include 16" tile floors, real wood floors/trim/crown-molding, floor-to-ceiling windows and cabinets, granite countertops and vanities, arched/vaulted/cathedral 9ft ceilings, formal dining room, newer appliances, and a breakfast bar. The large master suite overlooks the lake and boasts an expansive walk-in closet, walk-in tiled shower, and soaking tub. All meticulously loved and maintained. Hidden on a quiet dead-end road, walking distance to one of Monticello's best known eateries, five minutes to Indiana Beach and country clubs, and ten minutes to all of the downtown amenities. Make it yours today!

The view is just the start to this must see, 4 bedroom 4 bath Lake Freeman home. Beautiful wood floors, timeless kitchen features, and a double sided stone fireplace. Full finished basement. Large wrap around deck and a screened in porch. Extra large 3 car attached garage on a large lot.. Professionally landscaped. Covered boat slip and deck included. Very energy efficient home. You will love what you see!!

Charm is the key word for this darling five bedroom three bathroom home located on a quiet country road in Monticello. Stepping through the front door you will find a welcoming foyer leading directly to a large family room with a wall of windows allowing natural light to stream in and a fireplace with raised brick hearth. Wood beams on the ceiling elongate the space and add a cozy element that suites the home well. Adjacent to the living room is the dining which flows into a large kitchen with plenty of cabinet space and updated appliances. Also on the main floor is a the laundry, a full bath, and a large main bedroom with ensuite bath. Upstairs you will find an additional four bedrooms, all generously sized, and another full bathroom. This home definitely does not lack for space! The backyard offers plenty of privacy and is lined with lush forestry. This home is ready for YOUR finishing touches, hurry to see it!

MADE IN THE SHADE ON LAKE SHAFER! This spacious 2000+ sq. ft. year-round home has plenty of open living quarters along with 4 bedrooms & 2 full baths including the large master bed/bath combo. Or you can take the party outside to the 27 x 16 covered, attached deck OR enjoy the lake and the cool shade in the 16 x 16 screened-in cabin (VERY CUTE!) with it's own deck perched at the 70+ feet of shoreline. The lake level lot has great yard space, storage sheds and a 2+ car garage. Wooded peninsula across from your waterfront provides a scenic & quiet barrier from the hustle and bustle of the lake but you're still just seconds away if you want to do your own hustling & bustling!

Welcome to the river! Don't miss this opportunity with over 100 ft of Tippy River frontage. This home features 1492 square feet, 2 bedrooms, 2 full baths, open concept living and kitchen area. Spectacular views of the river front either from the wall of windows in living room or the full front deck that allows for entertaining and a separate private section from the master suite. Sunroom allows access to the main entrance of the home or the large deck! Extras include a large 2 car detached garage with an unfinished loft for storage, "party room" attached to garage for entertaining, etc. The yard is fully fenced in for privacy. The additional lot features a 20 X 30 carport for boats, RV's, etc. Flood insurance is required and amount will vary with any loan amount.

Crisp, clean, and move in ready. This two bedroom home in the heart of Monticello is in great condition and would make a perfect personal home or investment opportunity. Updated open kitchen, separate laundry area and more. The double lot leaves plenty of space to enjoy the outdoors.

Check out this 4 bedroom & 2 bath home that sits on a 1 acre lot and is in the Twin Lake School District! Main bedroom and private bath on one end of the home with the other 3 on the opposite side. Kitchen, dining and living room in the middle with an open concept layout which makes for a great time when entertaining family and friends. You will be able to let the youngins & pets run wild and free on this large lot that sits in a tucked away rural subdivision while still being close to town. Check it out today before it's too late!

Beautiful location on the river offering approximately 39 feet of water frontage and a pier. This 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom mobile home has an attached screened porch with 334 square feet and concrete floors. There is a shed near the waterfront for storage, well house and RV hookup available. So many opportunities with this property!!

Seller willing to pay $5,000 towards Buyerâs closing cost or to update the property! Come check out this great Waterfront Property with 90' of waterfrontage located on beautiful Lake Freeman and within walking distance to anything in town. Currently has 4bd 2ba with unfinished walkout basement. This property could be a Single-Family House with Mother-In-Law Suite or a Duplex with no modifications needed! Note: Pictures are from when property was vacant prior to current tenants.

Summer Fun! Are you looking for the perfect spot on the lake this summer? This Lakefront Cottage on Lake Freeman may be just for you! Adorable cottage/cabin with 3 bedrooms and one full bath. Knotty Pine in the family room. If you enjoy a level lakeside yard for games, sand bottom shoreline for swimming, and spacious open deck for sunbathing...then the search is over and now you can relax and enjoy the entire summer. This is a nice location for walking, running and bicycling. It is move in ready.

New England style home with 7 bedrooms and 7.5 baths! Each bedroom has a private bath. This 1.28 acre lot is a short walk to Indiana Beach and is encircled by tall-reaching trees. Nature surrounds you when sitting on the covered front porch. Master bath includes garden tub, shower and double vanity. Complete gourmet kitchen with stainless ref., oversized stove, trash compactor, dishwasher, freezer and island. Charming great room full of charm and character and is open to 2 large dining areas. Hard and soft wood plank floors, solid pine doors. Back yard is a park-like setting with many perennials, large deck, heated work-shop garage. Lake Shafer waterfront lot is also included at rear of property. Most bedroom furniture stays. Could be great investment property as this property is presently operating as The Black Dog Inn. So many possibilities. Court house records show date of original home before additions and remodeling which was completed in 1991